- Published on
The Passion of Creation, Leonid Pasternak, 19th century
I can’t resist a good alliteration, or another opportunity to talk about the books I love.
Welcome to Love at First Line, something I stole from my library’s entry shelf. (Thank you, Johnston County Libraries.)
If you’ve ever been in a writing workshop, or read a book on writing, you’ll have heard someone say that the first line of your work is the most important. Some writers have thoroughly disproved this (looking at you, Flannery) and opted for a cold-open by way of dialogue and action, parachuting the reader into the middle of the tension or lack thereof. Other writers feel the need to tell you exactly what goes wrong, letting us believe that we know what’s going to happen. Some seem to throw innocuous details at the reader or build a thesis to later be proven. Sometimes the first line doesn’t become relevant until the last line. And then, some writers just want to tug at our heartstrings, lowering us into the grave of disappointed hopes for a novel that promised so much in that first line, but delivered so little by the closing page. Names will not be named.
“I am thirty years old and that is nothing.”
– The Far Field, Madhuri Vijay
Sometimes an editor should follow the rules. Other times, an editor trusts their writer. In this case: knowing a contraction and comma would only take away from the delivery of that first line. A deadpan. Nearly flippant. No emphasis or inflection. It’s tempting to gloss over it. This way of speaking becomes so intrinsic and essential to our character, giving that first line the room to grow more insistent throughout the story.
“Colburn was standing with his mother in the kitchen
when she said go fetch your father.”
– Blackwood, Michael Farris Smith
when she said go fetch your father.”
– Blackwood, Michael Farris Smith
Again, there is a time to break with the conventions of our beloved manual of style. The no-quotes are to be used with great caution. Michael Farris Smith knows what he’s doing. This opening line not only precedes everything Colburn does in Blackwood, but also calls the reader back to this moment with the same hazy layer of memory superimposed over every new dispensation of the plot.
“All happy families are alike;
every unhappy family is unhappy in its own way.”
– Anna Karenina, Leo Tolstoy
every unhappy family is unhappy in its own way.”
– Anna Karenina, Leo Tolstoy
The canonized Russians usually have an argument to make through their characters. I would too if I were worried about Napoleon or being forcefully excused indefinitely to Siberia. Here, Tolstoy is declarative. He is speaking to every iteration of now and assumes his thesis will hold true for all of time. He isn’t giving us room to disagree.
“Whether I shall turn out to be the hero of my own life,
or whether that station will be held by anybody else, these pages must show.”
- David Copperfield, Charles Dickens*
There’s something special about authorial fingerprints. Dickens is telling a story by having his character dispense it directly to the reader. He is dispensing it uncertainly. This is a story of which we receive a judiciary invitation. Similarly to Anna Karenina, Charles Dickens uses the present-tense, immortalizing this question for all generations of readers and passing the responsibility of answering it onto us.
“The sixteen years of Janet’s life
began in wartime on a fog-bound winter night in Edinburgh.”
- O Caledonia: A Novel, Elspeth Barker
began in wartime on a fog-bound winter night in Edinburgh.”
- O Caledonia: A Novel, Elspeth Barker
We are told several things to expect: Janet will die by sixteen. She was born during a war in winter. We are at liberty to read her narration in Scottish brogue. Anything can be said and sound interesting in Scottish brogue. We are intrigued.
“Ships at a distance have every man’s wish on board.
For some they come in with the tide.
For others they sail on forever on the horizon,
never out of sight, never landing until the Watcher
turns his eyes away in resignation,
his dreams mocked to death by Time.
That is the life of men.”
- Their Eyes Were Watching God, Zora Neale Hurston
For some they come in with the tide.
For others they sail on forever on the horizon,
never out of sight, never landing until the Watcher
turns his eyes away in resignation,
his dreams mocked to death by Time.
That is the life of men.”
- Their Eyes Were Watching God, Zora Neale Hurston
I can’t not add the rest of the opening paragraph. This is easily the most famous opening in all of classic Black literature (there are many contenders). The first line is proverbial, but what follows is just short of knee-weakening. I remember having to put the book down and be horizontal for a while after starting it the first time. Hurston presents us with the what the life of men is, but with a very large "therefore" lingering in the reader's mind. Therefore: the life of women is not so. Therefore, the life of women is too often a consequence of the life of men, as we see with Janie. It’s not only pretty prose, but it’s terribly functional, and an epic way to thrust your reader into your story.
We want to hear your favorite first lines in literature! Leave a comment, or tag us on instagram @blue_ink_press with what books have made you fall in love at first line.
*Favoritism is unavoidable—the Russians and Dickens are housed in the same category of beloved in my mind and will therefore hold a tenure here. And Dev Patel makes a very fine Copperfield indeed.
About the Author:
Liz Sheth is a home educator and editor in Willow Spring, North Carolina. She loves french macaroons, antiquing, broody Victorian gentlemen, and re-runs of Monk. When she's not doing something with words, she's in the garden or longing to be in the garden.
0 Comments