BLUE INK BLOG

Published on
Picture
I know, I know. An editor who herself has never completed any of her WIPs? The shame. Let me explain. I'm not a writer, though I enjoy playing with words and stories and the great world of What If. I have always enjoyed starting a project more than actually seeing one to completion--being introduced to an idea and pulling its layers off, only to reassemble them via literary devices. Only now, I enjoy seeing your ideas fleshed out, and helping you reassemble them. So here's what I've learned:
​

You're trying too hard to be original

We live in a culture that prizes originality and authenticity, so it's not a surprise that, as creatives, our drive to build something new or invert tropes in never-done-before ways can eclipse the story we're actually interested in telling. Your editor isn't interested in whether you're the first person to write about such-and-such a thing in such-and-such a way. What you should be striving for instead is your own unique voice as a writer, not some monumental new idea. There's no great writer alive who doesn't acknowledge their influences, and give nod to them respectfully in their work, and yet their voices are distinct from their forebears. Everyone has great ideas, but not everyone knows how to tap into their own specific voice as a writer, and that's something that takes practice, trial, and--yes--error.
​

Your goal is to be an international bestseller

That's cute. Sit down. 
​

You're holed away in the attic and haven't spoken to anyone for three years

Perhaps it worked for Hozier and Bon Iver for writing a few of their songs, but alas, you and I are neither. We have to interact with the world in order to write about it. Artifice doesn't exclusively exist in the netherworld of your imagination. Regardless of whether your main character is a shapeshifting dragon who works in IT or a space cowboy who lassos the moon, your readers are people who require human ideas and human concerns to empathize with your metaphors. Creativity isn't born out of isolation, but it isn't an enemy to it, either. Dickens was known for walking around London with a notebook. You are not shackled to your desk. Inspiration is seldom found in a blinking cursor. Go outside and hiss at the sunlight for five minutes or something.
​

You're not a pants-er

We'd all like to be Stephen King and just shoot from the hip and sail through a manuscript on adrenaline and good ideas. But most of us (not all, mind you) require some level of organization to accomplish anything. Perhaps you write everything longhand, and organize scenes tangibly rather than through an application like Scrivener. Perhaps you keep notecards of important arcs, and rotate them around when the story isn't working. Perhaps they're even color-coded. Maybe you outline everything and character profile everyone before writing the first line to the first scene to the first act. Whatever it is you settle with to organize your story, it isn't a breech in creative protocol to take time to intentionally pull the details of the story out of your brain and into a catalogue for reference when you get lost, or the ideas change, or the characters start rewriting themselves. If you are a pants-er, congratulations. We're all jealous.
​

You're editing it to death

If you've been here five minutes, you'll see I love me some Flannery O'Connor. In one of my favorite short stories by her (I'd highly recommend it to all writers), "The Crop", a Miss Willerton is having an all-too-familiar spat with her typewriter. She's three lines in, edits it, edits it, edits it. Scraps it. Decides in a moment of inspiration that she ought to write about the Irish. The brogue. It's hilarious, and a keen reminder not to take yourself too seriously and wade into waters of pretention. Your goal for your first draft isn't for it to be presentable to publishers: it's to get the idea out of your head.

Translating ideas to paper is slippery work, and will require revisions and thorough corrections prior to submission, but save the revisions for after you've finished the work. Of course we want a clean, well-edited manuscript and we need to see you understand basic grammar. But perfect? We have a team for that. Revise after you've had beta-readers provide feedback. Feel like you used too many adjectives? Fix it in your third round of edits, not in the middle of repairing a scene. My job is to sleep with a copy of the Chicago Manual of Style, not yours. I need to know what you want to say before I decide you're not saying it right. Scram and leave some job security for me. 
​

You're writing about what you don't know

Let's say you're an upperclass American woman who's never set foot outside the continental U.S., and decide it's your mission to write from the perspective of a young boy living through, oh, I don't know, Apartheid. Or you're a hearing person who's never interacted with the D/deaf community, and your MC is Deaf. Perhaps don't. Ilya Kaminsky has a handle on that (See: Deaf Republic.) This isn't to say you should never include narratives that are outside your personal realm of experience--we see that representation matters--but there's a reason we have Own Voices authors, and when we superimpose ourselves into a market of ideas reserved for people who understand them more thoroughly than us, we remove their opportunities and, more than likely, get it disastrously wrong and build upon stereotypes that others are working to remove. Make room for them, and focus on what you know.

As another example: I had the idea in my head for months that I needed to write about a family migrating from Latvia. I am not Latvian. I do not know any Latvians. So why was I trying to make the entire narrative from the perspective of multiple generations of Latvians? Someone else has already done that, and I just needed to read their book and learn (See: Among the Living and the Dead by Inara Verzemnieks.) Just because you're fascinated by something doesn't mean it's for you to write about.

What's important to you?
​

You think you only have one story inside of you, and if you can't get it out, you should just quit

This one makes me sad, but it's what I see most often with aspiring writers who have spent years tinkering with one cast of characters. It makes sense. We're attached to our work. There's a reason they call it killing your darlings when we have to remove a passage or scene or character. It feels a little like grief, like cutting off your arm. However, I promise that there are more stories to tell than the first one you ever tried writing. Set it down, give it a nice home in your heart, and make room for something new. You've grown, life has had an impact on you in one way or another, and you have things to say that aren't what you would have said through those characters or through that plot. You're not betraying anything by putting an unfinished work to the side, and letting it breathe.
​
Picture

Author

About the Author: Liz Sheth is a home educator and editor in Willow Spring, North Carolina. She loves french macarons, antiquing, broody Victorian gentlemen, and re-runs of Monk. When she's not doing something with words, she's in the garden or longing to be in the garden.

0 Comments